Having been a parent for almost 10 years, I've made a lot of mistakes in the discipline department. Of course, we learn how to be good parents through trial and error, but there are some errors I wouldn't want anybody to have to repeat. So, to help new parents everywhere, I've offered my critique of the top two discipline strategies I do not recommend:
1. The Ominous Count
Sure, it'll work the first time you do it; that desperate moment when, faced with no other reasonable options and a defiant child, you turn into some kind of deranged Muppet from "Sesame Street" and begin forcefully counting out loud. Perhaps you have an end game in mind. Perhaps not. Either way, counting slowly and declaratively is exhilarating, an exercise in parental authority. "One...TWO....three..."
And the first time, that's usually as far as you'll have to get. The unexpectedness of it, your tone, that half-crazed gleam in your eye, all those will signal your child to stop whatever it is he's doing and cooperate, because whatever lies on the other side of five must be REALLY bad.
But don't think you'll be so lucky forever. Before too long, your counting routine will have lost its original zeal. Your child will decide it's worth the risk to stay around and see what you'll do when you get to five. And if you're like me, you have no idea. Out loud, you continue to count, while in your head, you desperately try to figure out what to do next:
"Five ... six ... seven ... eight ...nine ..." uh-oh, what am I going to do when I get to 10?
"Ten ... 11... 12 ... 13 ...." Shoot! I can't let myself get to 20. I have to come up with a plan pronto! But what? Think!
"Fourteen ... 15 ...." Finally, you realize this is going nowhere, and lamely try to get some resolution to the counting. "OK, you made me get to 15. Do you know what that means? No cookie after lunch!"
If your child is like mine, he gives up the cookie without flinching. Dissolving the power of the count? Priceless.
2. The Endless Bargain
Sometimes, giving choices can be an effective strategy. When dealing with my 3-year-old, for example, I might say "Do you want to get in your car seat by yourself or do you want me to put you in it?" Or I might say "Would you like to eat your carrots on your rice or next to your rice?" When he feels some amount of control over his destiny, he's a lot more agreeable.
I'm talking about a different kind of bargaining. The kind where, instead of two choices, the eager-to-be-accommodating parent offers a whole menu:
"Do you want to get in your car seat by yourself? No? OK, shall I put you in? No? OK, how about if I move your car seat to the other side of the car?" (Much sweating and grunting over car seat un-installation and re-installation ensues.)
At this point, the child starts to get the picture: if he can just keep his mom jumping through hoops, he might never actually have to get in the car seat. "NO! I wanted it over THERE!" he cries. At this point, many moms will realize they've been had, physically install their ungrateful kid into the seat, and take off to go shopping. But a handful will try harder to please. "Do you want to sit in the back row? Do you want to stay home and have juice instead?" And just like that, shopping is off the agenda.
Once in a while, it's nice to allow your kids to be the "boss," giving them the power to make a decision instead of always being told what to do. But the problem with the endless bargain is that the more options you give kids, the less likely that they'll be satisfied with any of them. My advice? Stick with giving two choices, and make sure both are acceptable to you. Otherwise, you just end up punishing yourself.
As for counting? I swore I'd given it up, but the other day Owen kept climbing up on the counter. I wanted my little daredevil to get down, so I held my arms out. He refused to budge. I found myself counting. "One ... two ..."
"THWEE-GO!" he yelled, leaping off the counter into my arms. For Owen, a new, exciting game was born. As for myself? I cursed the day I'd ever learned to count.
(as always, you can read past editions of my columns at the Lansing NOISE website)